The Ultimate Guide to Finding the Best Bread for Chicken Salad Sandwiches

Chicken salad sandwiches are a classic lunch staple, but finding the right bread to complement the flavors and textures of the filling can be a challenge.

Whether you prefer your chicken salad sandwich toasted or untoasted, light and fluffy or dense and chewy, the type of bread you choose can make all the difference.

See also the best fancy breads for brisket sandwiches.

In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the best bread options for chicken salad sandwiches, taking into account factors such as texture, flavor, and versatility. From artisan sourdough to classic white bread, we have you covered.

If you are interested what flour to use making bread see the differences on flour types vs bread flour.

5 Tips for Choosing the Best Bread for Chicken Salad Sandwiches

When it comes to making a chicken salad sandwich, choosing the right bread can make all the difference. Here are five tips to help you select the best bread for your sandwich.

1. Consider the Texture

The texture of the bread is important because it affects the overall mouthfeel of the sandwich.

If you prefer a chewy texture, look for denser breads like sourdough or whole wheat. If you prefer a lighter texture, consider a ciabatta or a soft white bread.

2. Think About Flavor

The flavor of the bread can also have a big impact on the overall taste of the sandwich. Consider the flavors of the chicken salad filling and choose a bread that complements or contrasts with the flavors in a desirable way.

For example, a sourdough bread can balance the creaminess and tanginess of the chicken salad, while a whole wheat bread can add a nutty, earthy flavor to the sandwich.

3. Take Toasting into Account

Whether you prefer your sandwich toasted or untoasted, choose a bread that will hold up well under heat. A denser bread like sourdough or whole wheat will hold up better when toasted, while a lighter bread like ciabatta may become too crunchy and break apart.

4. Look for Freshness

Fresh bread is key to a delicious chicken salad sandwich. Consider buying your bread from a local bakery or farmer’s market, or look for a grocery store with a high-quality bakery section that bakes fresh bread daily.

5. Experiment with Buns 

Experimenting with different types of buns can take your chicken salad sandwiches to the next level! Trying a variety of buns can open up all sorts of creative opportunities.

Pretzel buns and potato rolls are two unique options that are both delicious and easily available. Sweet Hawaiian rolls will add a touch of sweetness to an otherwise savory dish.

Multi-grain buns, focaccia, and sourdough are also great options for changing up the flavor of your sandwich. Depending on the ingredients you use in your chicken salad, you can find a type of bun to complement them perfectly.

You can even make your own homemade buns or rolls to bring it all together into one unforgettable experience!

So wrapping up the sandwich bread tips 

When choosing the best bread for a chicken salad sandwich, consider factors such as texture, flavor, and freshness. Experiment with different types of bread to find the perfect option for your tastes and preferences. With these tips, you’re sure to find the perfect bread for your chicken salad sandwich.

Top 15 Breads For Making Chicken Salad Sandwiches in 2024

Tantalize your taste buds with the best bread for chicken salad sandwiches!

Now let’s look at each bread individually.

1. Artisan Sourdough Bread

Artisan sourdough bread is a great option for those looking for a unique and flavorful sandwich base. The sour flavor of the bread perfectly balances the creamy, tangy taste of the chicken salad, while the dense, chewy texture adds a satisfying bite to each bite.

Artisan sourdough bread can be found at specialty bakeries and local farmers markets, ensuring a fresh and delicious sandwich every time.

2. Focaccia Bread

Focaccia bread is a delicious Italian flatbread that is perfect for making chicken salad sandwiches. The lightly seasoned, buttery bread has a soft, chewy center and crispy exterior that is ideal for loading up with your favorite ingredients and sandwich fillings!

Focaccia bread also stands up well to moisture from condiments or dressings without getting soggy or falling apart. This makes it an excellent choice for making all types of sandwiches. Plus, the extra flavor added by the herbs and other seasonings will make your sandwich even better.

Made with yeast, olive oil, and seasonings like rosemary and oregano, focaccia bread is easy to make at home but can also be purchased already pre-made in most grocery stores. And because it’s so versatile, you can use focaccia bread for more than just chicken salad sandwiches—try some grilled cheese or veggie paninis!

3. Whole Wheat Bread

Whole wheat bread is a nutritious and delicious choice for chicken salad sandwiches. It has a whole grain flavor that’s perfect with the creamy, slightly tart dressing in a classic chicken salad sandwich.

Plus, it has lots of fiber, protein and nutrients to fuel you during your busy day! Plus, it’s fairly easy to find in grocery stores and bakeries.

You’ll love the crunchy texture of whole wheat toast with juicy chunks of chicken paired with pungent onions and herbs in your chicken salad sandwich. It’s perfect for an outdoor picnic or an easy lunch at work.

Whole wheat bread can be found at nearly any grocery store, making it a convenient and accessible option for anyone looking for a healthier sandwich.

4. Ciabatta Bread

Ciabatta bread is a great option for those looking for a light, airy texture. The bread’s large, open crumb structure allows for plenty of space for the chicken salad filling, making each bite a true flavor explosion.

See how to store ciabatta bread

Ciabatta Bread is the perfect choice for a chicken salad sandwich. Its chewy texture provides a nice contrast to the soft Chicken Salad, and its large size makes it easy to stuff with a generous portion.

Plus, Ciabatta Bread has just the right amount of crunch to provide some texture without overpowering the flavor of the sandwich’s main ingredient – chicken!

When selecting Ciabatta Bread, look for loaves that have a deep golden-brown crust, with an open crumb and slightly sticky texture. This type of bread has a more complex flavor profile than ordinary sandwich bread, so it adds more depth of flavor to your Chicken Salad Sandwich.

Try adding some herbs or flavored olive oil to make Ciabatta Bread even tastier! With this flavorful combination you’ll be sure to get your guests’ taste buds dancing for joy!

5. Classic White Bread

Classic white bread is the best choice for making chicken salad sandwiches. Its mild taste and tight crumb, allow it to support the flavors of the sandwich fillings without overwhelming them.

Plus, its spongy and light texture creates a satisfying crunch as you bite into the sandwich. Plus, you can find classic white bread in pretty much any grocery store or bakery!

White bread also works with other alternatives too, like making a wrap or cutting into cubes for a picnic salad. The possibilities are endless when it comes to this classic bakery staple.

The simplicity of white bread makes it perfect for busy meal prep days, too since you don’t have to worry about fancy ingredients or extra steps to get dinner on the table.

6. Naan

Naan is an excellent choice for chicken salad sandwiches. The warm and fluffy texture of naan will lend itself perfectly to this classic sandwich.

For a truly indulgent treat, opt for garlic and seasoned herb naan. This adds a robust flavor to the chicken salad, transforming the ordinary into something extraordinary!

Naan is also a great option if you are looking for an alternative to traditional sandwich bread. Its thicker consistency holds in all your favorite ingredients but still offers a light and airy taste that can’t be matched.

Plus, forget about soggy sandwiches! The thickness of naan keeps your sandwich crisp even when loaded with creamy chicken salad. From flavor to texture, naan is one of the best bread for your chicken salad sandwich!

 7. Pita

When it comes to the best bread for chicken salad sandwiches, pita is a great choice. It’s perfect for holding all that delicious filler in one neat and manageable package!

Pita bread is soft and foldable which makes it great for snacking on the go. Plus, the pockets hold your sauce, spread and all that juicy chicken salad without getting soggy.

It’s also relatively low in calories; one pocket has around 150-180 calories depending on size so you still feel good after you eat. Additionally, some pitas are made with very few ingredients and are usually not overly sweet like some other breads can be.

Plus, pita pairs well with so many different flavors – even veggies! Whether you prefer it grilled or sliced and toasted lightly, pita is an excellent option for your next chicken salad sandwich.

8. Baguette

If you want a classic chicken salad sandwich, the go-to bread choice is the baguette. This French-style toasted white bread is light and airy but still firm enough to hold a generous portion of delicious chicken salad.

What makes baguettes stand out from other types of bread? They’re crunchy outside, soft inside, and great for sandwiches. The flavor of a lightly toasted baguette can really make your chicken salad sandwich pop!

Plus, because of their size, you’ll be able to get two sandwiches out of just one baguette– so it’s perfect for if you’re making lunch for yourself or for a friend! With its buttery crispiness and traditional look, this type of bread pairs perfectly with all types of homemade chicken salads.

9. Rye Bread

When preparing chicken salad sandwiches, rye bread is a popular option. It provides a delicious nutty flavor that pairs perfectly with creamy chicken and crunchy vegetables.

Rye bread also has great texture and has fewer calories when compared to other types of breads. This makes it the ideal choice for people watching their weight as they can enjoy their sandwich without blowing their calorie goals.

Another advantage of using rye bread is that it’s more resistant to getting soggy when compared to other types of bread. This happens because Rye contains some natural oils that help keep it firm even when exposed to moisture.

All these advantages make rye bread a great choice for all your sandwich recipes, particularly for chicken salads!

10. Multigrain Bread

Multigrain bread makes a great choice when making chicken salad sandwiches. This nutty textured bread is filled with vitamins, minerals and fiber.

It’s made using three or more whole grains and usually has wheat, rye, oats, barley, spelt and millet among the ingredients.

Multigrain breads are generally denser than white breads as they use multiple flours to make the dough which gives it a unique flavor. The subtle nuttiness of multigrain bread complements the flavors of chicken salad so enjoy it guilt-free!

The mix of different grains present in multigrain bread also means that it’ll provide you with a delicious burst of crunchy texture and rich flavor to your sandwich. So say goodbye to boring chicken salads on plain white bread and start creating unforgettable sandwiches today!

11. Brioche

Brioche is a French-style bread that goes really well with chicken salad sandwiches. It’s a rich, eggy-textured light golden-brown loaf with an unmistakable buttery flavor that comes through when toasted.

The fluffy texture provided by brioche helps to keep the sandwich together so the ingredients do not fall out of the sides. The soft, buttery brioche also adds a touch of sweetness and moisture to each bite.

Another bonus of using brioche for your chicken salad sandwich is its lightness. The lighter texture doesn’t overpower the delicate flavors of chicken salad, yet it still provides enough body so they hold up in your hands while eating them!

Brioche makes the perfect bread choice for even the pickiest eater and just one bite will prove it!

12. Pumpernickel Bread

Pumpernickel Bread is a dark German-style rye bread. It’s perfect for sandwiches because it has a slightly sour taste that really enhances the flavor of chicken salad!

The strong flavor of pumpernickel is one of its best qualities. When your sandwich relies on something like an egg or chicken salad filling, you want a bread that will provide a unique, delightful contrast in taste and texture.

It also has a hearty bite to it and if you choose to make paninis you’ll love the crunchy exterior it provides with each bite. Pumpernickel Bread is the perfect choice when making flavorful, memorable sandwiches!

13. Bao Buns

Welcome to the delicious world of Bao buns! These fluffy, Asian-style steamed bread buns make for a perfect sandwich carrier. And what makes these buns even more unique is their distinct chewy dough consistency.

Bao Buns are great in chicken salad sandwiches because their sweetness balances out the savory and natural saltiness of the meat. The dough is moist, so it holds up well against moist fillings like chicken salad.

And if you want some extra crunch, Toast them before eating for an unforgettable textural experience that’s bursting with flavorful goodness – it’s an unbeatable combination! Try them, and you won’t be disappointed!

14. Bagels

Bagels are perfect for sandwiches. The chewy texture holds everything together and won’t fall apart or get soggy as other bread will.

Plus, the variety of flavors available, from plain, onion, sesame, etc., gives you ample opportunities to create delicious combinations for chicken salad sandwich recipes!

Bagels come in many shapes and sizes, so no matter what size your chicken salad sandwich is, you should be able to find the right fit. Not only that, but split bagels provide a better crust-to-filling ratio – ensuring every bite tastes even better!

Overall, bagels are an excellent choice when it comes to making chicken salad sandwiches. They’re sturdy enough to hold all the ingredients inside without crumbling, and they come in plenty of flavors that accentuate the flavor of your homemade chicken salad recipe.

15. English Muffins

English muffins are a great choice for chicken salad sandwiches. They have a sturdy texture that doesn’t get soggy when combined with meat and other sandwich ingredients.

Plus, their nooks and crannies help contain the dressing that would otherwise make the bread too soggy in your sandwich.

What makes them even better is they come in different flavors like multigrain, plain, cinnamon-raisin, onion or blueberry. So keep an eye on what your grocery store offers!

Best of all, English muffins tend to toast perfectly—adding a nice crunch to your chicken salad sandwich without any extra effort.

Tips On Making Chicken Salad From the Store Better For Sandwiches

If you’re using store-bought chicken salad for a sandwich, it can be a little on the bland side. The good news is that with a few ingredients, you can give your chicken salad an awesome flavor boost.

Try adding in some fresh herbs like basil, rosemary, or thyme; diced red onion; chopped celery; and/or shredded carrots. All of these ingredients add texture and flavor so your chicken salad doesn’t taste flat or boring.

You could also try adding in some crunchy items like roasted nuts, raisins, dried apricots, sliced grapes, pepperoncini’s, and crispy bacon! All of these additions will turn your store-bought chicken salad into an amazing sandwich filling.

Once you have all of your yummy mix-ins ready to go, just lightly fold them into the store-bought chicken salad before scooping it onto your favorite bread and assembling the ultimate delicious sandwich!

Does Chicken Salad Go Well On bread

The type of bread you choose for your chicken salad sandwich will definitely make or break the flavor! But, which kind is best?

It really depends on which type of chicken salad sandwich you want to create – whether classic, croissant, wrap or open-face. Generally speaking, whole grain sandwich breads are the tastiest option for a chicken salad sandwich.

They provide a robust base for all that crunchy goodness and keep everything together (no one likes a dry salad!). But if you’re looking for something lighter and sweeter, try using brioche buns.

These soft rolls will give you an almost dessert-like combination when paired with the creamy chicken salad filling. Whatever type of bread you choose, it’s bound to be delicious!

Conclusion

“Uncovering the Perfect Bread for Your Chicken Salad Sandwich: A Guide to Elevating Your Meal Experience”

When it comes to creating a delicious chicken salad sandwich, choosing the right type of bread can be a game-changer. The bread you select can either enhance or detract from the overall flavor and texture of the meal. In this guide, we will explore the top bread options for your chicken salad sandwich and help you make an informed decision to elevate your dining experience.

Here is our Summary of Top breads and why.

• Sourdough – The Classic Choice
  • Sourdough bread is a staple in many households and is a popular option for chicken salad sandwiches. Its tangy flavor and chewy texture pair perfectly with the creamy and crunchy ingredients in the sandwich. Whether you prefer a thick slice or a thin one, sourdough is a versatile bread that can accommodate your personal taste.
• Ciabatta – The Italian Touch
  • Ciabatta, a traditional Italian bread, is another great choice for your chicken salad sandwich. With its airy crumb and crispy crust, ciabatta provides a contrast in texture that elevates the overall experience. The mild flavor of ciabatta allows the flavors of the chicken salad to shine through, making it a top pick for those who prefer a more neutral bread.
• Baguette – The French Connection
  • For a more traditional French twist, consider a baguette for your chicken salad sandwich. Baguettes are known for their crisp crust and soft interior, providing a satisfying crunch in every bite. The delicate flavor of the baguette will not overpower the chicken salad, making it an excellent choice for those who like to keep it simple.
• Focaccia – The Hearty Option
  • Focaccia, an Italian flatbread, is a hearty option for your chicken salad sandwich. With its soft and chewy texture, focaccia provides a comforting feel to the sandwich. The olive oil used in the preparation of focaccia gives it a distinct flavor that complements the chicken salad well. If you are looking for a filling and flavorful option, focaccia is a great choice.
• Whole Wheat and Multigrain – The Healthier Alternatives
  • For those who prefer healthier options, whole wheat and multigrain breads are excellent choices for your chicken salad sandwich. These breads are packed with nutrients and provide a wholesome feel to the sandwich. Whole wheat bread has a nutty flavor that pairs well with the chicken salad, while multigrain bread provides a more complex flavor profile with its various grains.
• Rye and Pumpernickel – The Dark and Rich
  • Options Rye and pumpernickel breads are perfect for those who prefer a darker and richer flavor. These breads have a denser texture and a bold flavor that can stand up to the chicken salad. Whether you prefer a thin slice or a thick one, rye and pumpernickel breads are great options for those who want a more robust flavor profile.
• Brioche – The Sweet Option Brioche
  • A French sweet bread, is a unique choice for your chicken salad sandwich. With its rich and buttery flavor, brioche provides a sweet contrast to the savory chicken salad. The soft texture of brioche also adds a comforting feel to the sandwich. If you are in the mood for something a little sweeter, brioche is a great option.

So next time you’re making a chicken salad sandwich, consider trying a new type of bread to elevate your lunch game. Your taste buds will thank you!