Club Soda vs Soda Water they’re Actually Different

Club Soda Vs Soda Water They’re Actually Quite Different In 2024

We grew up drinking simple water out from the bottle. Now, as time and technology advance, different kinds and tastes of water have evolved many using sodium bicarbonate. In fact, when you order in a restaurant, you may be more confused when asked this question: Do you want a carbonated beverage – “Flat or sparkling?” Not often now do we just get asked do we want tap water?

Just take a look at the beverage aisle in the grocery store and you will see different a huge array of waters that you can choose. You can either have club soda, soda water, sparkling water, seltzer water, flavored seltzer, flavored sparkling water, bubbly water, natural flavor mineral salts soft drink, or fizzy water.  And I have not even listed all of them.

What really is the difference between club soda and soda water since these two are often used interchangeably. Club Soda vs Soda Water they’re actually quite different with the main difference soda water is a naturally carbonated product whereas club soda is force carbonated.

We will examine the differences in their ingredients and how each is manufactured. 

Also, see how many sodas you need for a large group, and can you drink expired soda?

Is Club Soda and Soda Water The Same?

No. Though they have similarities they are definitely not the same. Let’s talk about what makes them similar first. 

Club soda and soda water are both classified as carbonated water from carbon dioxide gas. This is the type of water that is created by dissolving the carbon dioxide in water under pressure. The dissolution of the gas results in effervescence that gives a fizzing sound from released gas when you open the bottle. 

Moreover, carbonated water looks the same. It can occur naturally and unnaturally. Naturally, carbonated water has a bubbly bite without a flavor while the others usually contain additives or dissolved solids that can give a range of salty or sweet flavors to the carbonated drink.

The major difference between these two carbonated drinks of water is that club soda is unnatural while soda water is naturally carbonated. 

What Is Soda Water

Soda water is naturally carbonated water that people can drink. It comes from the environment’s mineral springs. Soda water is made by separating carbon dioxide from the water itself, which is called the purification process. The purified water will be then added back to the carbon dioxide may be with added salt to improve the taste. 

club soda vs sparkling water
club soda vs sparkling water

What is Club Soda

Club soda is a type of water that has added minerals like potassium bicarbonate, sodium chloride, sodium citrate, citric acid, baking soda, and potassium sulfate. Sometimes they may also put trace amounts of artificial sweetener in – so you will need to read the label carefully. It also has carbonation that is artificially injected, hence making it manufactured carbonated water. The amount of additives in this drink depends varies on each producer, giving it different tastes. It is also one of the most common bubbly drinks that you can get in diners and clubs. 

How Does Club Soda and Soda Water Differ in Taste

These two drinks may be the same when it comes to being carbonated but they have quite different tastes.

Also, the carbonation process of waters affects their overall taste. 

Club soda typically tastes saltier because of the sodium that is added to the mixed drink. As previously mentioned, its salty taste may vary depending on the amount of sodium added during the formulation. Some products have a bubbly plain diet soda taste while others taste more bitter.  

While the soda water can taste sour or tart due to the carbon dioxide combined in the water. Some manufacturers of these products will add flavor to soda water to lessen the bitter taste and that is why you see soda water being advertised as flavored with natural lime, mandarin, orange, or lemon additives.

How Does Club Soda and Soda Water Differs in Their Origins

In 1767, carbonated water was discovered by Joseph Priestly. It was through his fascination of science that he was able to discover this.  He lived next to a brewery in England wherein he used to leave a suspended bowl of water over a beer vat. This resulted in a reaction that he, later on, experimented with. He used a gas mixture contained in a pig’s bladder that made his own carbonated water. And since most people (at the time and now) find this weird and gross, he quickly moved to use glass containers that later on labeled as soda water. 

On the other hand, club soda originated in Dublin, Ireland. It is a classic drink in 1877 that was introduced as water that can improve a person’s health. It was advertised as a drink from a cold neutralized lactic acid initially. When it became popular the lactic acid was dropped and the carbonated drink industry was onto a winner. Innovation then began to where we are today with many varieties and also the of course making your own homemade soda with a soda siphon.

What are the Pros and Cons of Drinking Carbonated Water

We all know that our bodies need a good amount of water to get through the day. Being dehydrated is never a good idea, that is why medical professionals always remind us to drink plenty of water each day. However, drinking carbonated water might be a different story. Though this kind of water contributes to our hydration, some have added sugars and artificial sweeteners, which might not be good for us. With that, here are some pros and cons of drinking carbonated water:


If you are on a restricted diet, take carbonated water as an alternative to your cola since it has fewer calories. It also provides hydration since it contains more water than sweeteners than soft drinks. 

Studies have shown that individuals who frequently drink carbonated waters have doubled their bowel movement frequency than those who drank plain water or regular water.

Carbonated waters make an individual increase their feeling of fullness. Thus, drinking enough carbonated water can help you feel satisfied longer and consume fewer calories throughout the day.


The bubbles and gases present in club soda and soda water can make you feel bloated or gassy. Different bodies react to carbonated water, so be sure to be mindful of your body’s reaction. 

Some carbonated waters are high in sugar content compared to regular water, hence it can affect tooth decay. Before purchasing one, make sure to read the label and check how many grams of sugar are present in the drink. To prevent tooth decay, make sure to practice good oral hygiene by alternating the use of carbonated water with plain water to cleanse your enamel and the entire mouth. 

Homemade Soda Water
Homemade Soda Water

Are Carbonated Waters As Healthy As Regular Water

Carbonated waters such as soda water, club soda, and tonic water are available anywhere and present us with so many choices it is sometimes hard to think which one should I buy.

But are they really good as regular water? 

According to different studies, carbonated waters hydrate just as regular waters. So, yes, it is as healthy as your regular water from the fridge from that perspective. As long as the drink does not have added sugar or other artificial additives then it is great for your body. 

Know that most brands add sodium or sugar that might cause weight gain. That is why you must check the nutrition label before buying.

Moreover, tonic water and club soda are usually the ones that contain added ingredients. Tonic water contains a lot of sugar or sweetener, usually quinine hence it should not be used in place of drinking sparkling water or regular water. Tonic water is best left to mixing with gin, or other spirits and not used for hydration.

Club soda usually has more than 70 mg of sodium per can and therefore shouldn’t be consumed regularly either.

What’s the Difference Between Club Soda, Seltzer, Tonic, and Mineral Water

Carbonated waters come in several forms. The most common products are club soda, soda water, seltzer water, mineral water, and tonic water. All of these are healthy assuming that there are no added sugars and flavorings. The major differences are these:

Seltzer water is kind of the same as soda water if there are no added, commercial ingredients to it. However, seltzer water is made from artificially carbonated while soda water is made differently; it is found or made from springs that have a naturally style carbonated water.

Mineral water also comes from a spring but it is processed in either flat or carbonated water. While soda water is only produced as carbonated and no other options.

Tonic water is similar to club soda. The primary difference is that tonic water contains more additives and calories. It also has a bitter flavor because of its quinine content. And since it has a bitter taste, it usually contains added sugar or sweeteners.

What’s the Difference Between Club Soda, Seltzer, Sparkling, and Tonic Water?

The best way to answer this is, club soda, seltzer, sparkling, and tonic water are all different types of carbonated drinks – but as we have described above only use natural waters with no or minimal additives for body hydration.

Soda Siphon
Soda Siphon

Does Club Soda Have Sugar?

A real Club soda does not contain any sugar. The only contents of club soda are water, a form of sodium or potassium, and carbon dioxide used in carbonation.

Can I Use Club Soda Instead Of Soda Water?

Yes, you can – they are largely interchangeable – just check the labels first if you are concerned, or plan to drink a lot of one product.

What Is The Same As Soda Water

Homemade, via a soda siphon, is the same as soda water.

Is Soda Water Just Sparkling Water

In its simplest form, yes, but check the label to make sure there are no sugary soda additives.

Is Soda Water The Same As Tonic Water

No, tonic water contains many additives, and drinking sparkling water for hydration is much better.

Club soda and soda water are two different things. If you’re a bartender, you’ll know the difference. But for those of us who aren’t, here’s the scoop. Club soda is carbonated water that’s been flavored with salt and sodium benzoate. It doesn’t have any caffeine or sugar added, but it does have a slightly salty taste. Soda water is the same as club soda in that it’s carbonated, It’s very light and refreshing and has a slightly sweet taste.

What is the best alternative for Golden Syrup?