Substitute for Quince Paste

Quince Paste is a traditional British dessert that is made from quinces and sugar. It is very similar to marmalade, which is also made from quinces. So, if you are looking for a substitute for quince paste, go for marmalade! Other than that, we also listed down other substitutes for quince paste and their degree of alternative capability.

In addition, we have also provided a recipe to make your own quince paste at home.

You may also be interested in these substitution articles

What are the Best Substitutes for Quince Paste

1. Marmalade

Marmalade is a sweet spread or jelly made with citrus fruits like oranges, lemons, limes, grapefruit, etc. The most common type of marmalade is orange-based fruit preserve. Marmalades vary by their flavors depending on which fruits they are made from and how they’re processed. There are different types of marmalades available depending upon the fruit’s sweetness and tartness levels. This is the most common substitution for quince paste in Europe.

Why is marmalade a good substitute for quince paste?

Marmalades have an intense flavor that goes well with desserts and other savory dishes. They can be used as a filling for cakes and pies or eaten on their own. In addition, they contain antioxidants that help fight toxins in the body.

2. Guava Paste

Guava paste is a popular tropical fruit jam made from guavas through a paste form. This delicious fruit has a rich, tangy taste that makes it perfect for jams and jellies. These are usually sold in jars or cans. You can find them at any grocery store. It goes well with any kind of dessert, especially for a cheese platter, cheese boards, tarts, and cookies. You could use it as an appetizer too!

Why is guava jam a good substitute for quince paste?

This jam has a unique flavor that goes well with many foods. It contains high amounts of vitamin C, potassium, fiber, and iron. You just have to eat this in moderation since it contains high granulated sugar content. Moreover, the thick consistency is similar to Quincy paste, thus the latter can also be a good substitute for guava paste.

Quince Paste Substitutes
Quince Paste Substitutes

3. Apple Sauce

Apple sauce is a smooth, thin, sweetened sauce made from apples. It is commonly served with pork, chicken, fish, and vegetables. It is often found in supermarkets and restaurants. You can make your own version using fruit preserve apples. Its floral aroma and taste will definitely enhance any food with a sweet flavor. 

Why is apple sauce a good substitute for quince paste?

The main ingredient in apple sauce is fresh apples, which are similar in flavor to quince. Thus, it will work great as a replacement for quince paste. However, you should note that its texture is not as firm as that of quince paste. Also, it does not contain much protein, so it cannot be considered a completely nutritious meal or snack for you. To make the apple sauce, it should be blended paste and not have chunks on it.

4. Pears and Lemon Rind

Pears are a common substitute for quince paste. This sweet fruit has a floral flavor with a combination of sweetness. The lemon rind is important to balance the flavor, giving a bit of tartness just like quince paste. When choosing pears, it does not matter what kind it is but pick those that are ripe enough to be easily blended with a softer texture. 

Why are pears and lemon rind a good substitute for quince paste?

You can use pears instead of quince because they are very close in flavor and texture. The lemon rind adds a little bit of acidity to the dish. Both ingredients go well together when paired with cheeses, meats, and salads.

Black Cherry Preserve is an Alternative for Quince Paste
Black Cherry Preserve is an Alternative for Quince Paste

5. Black Cherry Preserve

The black cherry preserve is composed of caramelized sweet black cherries with granulated sugar. This fruit preserve commonly mixes well with lemon juice to give a tart taste like the quince paste. To preserve its flavor and texture, you need to place the paste in an airtight container or sterilized glass jars.

Why is black cherry preserve a good substitute for quince paste?

Black cherry preserves are easy to prepare and have a strong fruity flavor. They can be used as a topping for desserts such as cakes and pies. If you do not want to buy the preserved black cherries, you can simply blend some fresh ones into a mixture of water and sugar. Then, simmer the mixture until it becomes syrupy.

Is Quince Paste Healthy

Quince paste or Dulce de Membrillo is commonly served during gatherings and parties because it gives fulfilling flavor, nutritious content, and health benefits. This fruit contains a massive amount of medicinal properties because of its diverse chemical composition. According to a study, it is a nutritional and dietary food source that contains vitamins, minerals, carbohydrates, fat, fibers, and proteins. All of these are essential to the body. Plus, the floral taste enhances sweet dishes on the table!

It is a good source of vitamin A, B6, C, E, K, folate, magnesium, phosphorus, and zinc. These nutrients help maintain overall health. In addition, it contains antioxidants that fight free radicals and prevent cancer. Therefore, quince paste is a healthy alternative to other jams and jellies.

What Food Pairs Perfectly with Quince

Since quince paste is a versatile food, it can be used in different recipes, but the best ones are Manchego cheese and blue cheese. Other than that, it can also go well with these:

  • toast
  • meat
  • crackers
  • sandwiches
  • pastry stuffing
  • spread in cakes
Marmalade Is one of the best Substitutes For Quince Paste
Marmalade Is one of the best Substitutes For Quince Paste

How to Make a Homemade Quince Paste

Are you looking for a paste or jam to serve along with your side dishes? Here is an easy homemade quince paste recipe that you can follow!

Preparation and Cooking Time: 1 hour and 15 minutes


  • 2 pounds quince 
  • 3 1/2 cups white granulated sugar or brown sugar 
  • 1 1/2tablespoons lemon juice
  • 1 cup water


1. Prepare a medium-sized pot over medium heat and place all the ingredients together. Stir thoroughly until the sugar has melted or caramelized. If it wrinkles or bubbles, then the hot mixture is ready to be taken off the heat. 

2. Prepare a medium-sized or 9-inch baking dish and grease it. 

3. Puree the jam mixture using a blender or anything similar to make it into a paste form. 

4. Pour the mixture into the baking dish. Let it cool for a couple of minutes and wrap with plastic wrap for at least 24 hours. 

5. If ready to be served, pair it with Manchego cheese or serve it together with your cheese platter. 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is quince paste made of?

Quince paste is made from cooked quinces which are then ground up and mixed with sugar, which is its common ingredient. It is usually stored in sterilized glass jars. The paste is very thick and sticky.

What is a quince fruit similar to?

A quince fruit looks like a large pear. It has yellow skin and deep red flesh. It tastes sweet and sour when ripe.

Does guava paste melt?

Guava paste melts easily since it has a high moisture level. However, if you store it properly, it will last longer. To make sure that the paste does not melt, place it on an airtight container or glass jar cover with plastic wrap, wax paper, or lid.